Electric versus petrol car: which is cheaper?

This September, one of our directors (Stephen) replaced his 2013 Toyota Auris hybrid (mostly petrol) with a MG4 electric car. How much will he save? Let’s do a simple calculation based on the miles each car does in practice on a full tank/charge.

 

Toyota Auris hybrid: 45 litre engine, does c. 440 miles on a full tank.

Ave. UK petrol price (at time of checking): 172.02 p. per litre.

(45 litres x 172.02 p. per litre)/440 miles = 17.59 p. per mile.

Stephen & his wife drive c. 6,000 miles p.a., so the Auris costs £1,056 p.a. to run.

 

MG4 SE Long Range, 64 kWh battery, does c. 250 miles on a full charge.

Stephen’s Octopus Cosy tariff off-peak rate: 12.54 p. per kWh.

(64 kWh x 12.54 p. per kWh)/250 miles = 3.21 p. per mile.

6,000 x 3.21 p. = £193 p.a. to run!

 

The MG4 is £863 a year cheaper to run!

 

We should mention winter though: EVs tend to have a lower range in cold conditions. Stephen hasn’t experienced that yet, but some online information suggests that his MG4 might only do 190 miles in “winter conditions”. That refers to minus 10 degrees though, rather than an average UK winter day of around 6 degrees. So from now on, let’s assume an average range of about 230 miles on a full charge. Stephen will then pay £209 p.a. on his Octopus Cosy tariff – the lower average range only adds £16 to the cost.

 

Speaking of the seasons, Stephen plans to switch to a cheaper tariff than Octopus Cosy over the summer, which could mean further savings. Cosy is necessary for the winter, to run a heat pump (which uses over 40 kWh on the coldest winter days). With only a 10 kWh battery, he won’t get through a winter day on an overnight EV tariff.

 

If Stephen had a bigger home battery that could handle this, then he could charge the car on a tariff like Octopus’ Intelligent Go: the current fixed tariff advertised online is 8.4 p. per kWh. The 6,000 miles would then cost only £140 p.a. (assuming a 230 mile range). Or perhaps it could be even lower – the variable version of Intelligent Go offers even cheaper rates than the fixed version: at e.g. 7 p. per kWh, 6,000 miles in the MG4 would cost only £117. If we assume Stephen’s family are on a tariff at that rate for 6 months of the year, and on Cosy for the other 6 months, he may be able to get down to around £150 p.a.

 

Even charging at the current electricity price cap of 26.32 p. per kWh, the 6,000 miles would only cost £439 p.a, £617 less than with the Auris. In fact, even charging on slower public chargers, Stephen would only pay £902 p.a., still c. £150 less than at the petrol station. Only by constantly using fast chargers would he pay more than filling the Auris would cost (£1,286).

 

It’s not all good news. Stephen found the insurance for the MG4 was around £300 higher than for the Auris. EVs break down less often, but when they do they are more often uneconomical to repair, meaning insurance rates are higher. Hopefully this will change with time. But even with that, the MG4 will save c. £580 a year.

 

If the government gets round to introducing its silly EV movement tax of 3 p. per mile travelled, the 6,000 miles will cost an extra £180 p.a. So the EV would then “only” save Stephen c. £400 a year.

 

And there’s another final piece of good news: because EVs have simpler mechanisms, repair and servicing costs tend to be lower, by around 23% according to one study. We might guess that could save Stephen around £100 a year. Of course, there’s always the chance you could get unlucky on this front and end up with a big repair bill, whatever car you drive.

 

Putting that all together, Stephen’s new MG4 is likely to save his family in the region of £370 – £700 pounds a year.

 

Some qualifications: we should remember this is based on specific models. The MG4 SE Long Range is quite efficient for a 2023 model, and other EVs might perform slightly less well. On the other hand, the Auris is not even a full petrol car, but a 2013 hybrid. It’s not that effective as a hybrid, and newer petrol cars are more efficient, but it is more efficient than a 2013 petrol car. So if you’re an aficionado of the “drive my old banger into the ground” theory, your petrol car is likely costing you even more to run than we’ve considered here.

 

Secondly, of course, prices will change. Current expectation is that petrol prices will continue to rise and electricity prices will fall in October, but electricity prices will probably rise a bit higher in January. Where they remain in the medium term is anyone’s guess, and wild swings are clearly possible, but this is unlikely to close a gap as big as £370 – £700. Long term, the trend should be for the cost of electricity should continue to fall as more renewables are installed.

 

Thirdly, these calculations leave standing charges aside. These seem to be high across the board, and don’t make a big difference.

 

Fourth, obviously, if you drive more than 6,000 miles p.a., the savings will be higher. And of course, if you only drive 1,000 miles p.a. the savings won’t be so impressive.

 

Finally, we haven’t even talked about diesel, which is currently much more expensive than petrol. If you’re driving a diesel, it would seem a good time to look at switching.